About Middle Cay

Middle Cay is a hidden gem in the Caribbean, offering a two-acre private sanctuary just off Harbour Island. This exclusive retreat features two luxurious villas set amidst a lush coconut grove, with five-star services, including a private chef and daily housekeeping. Ideal for boating enthusiasts, Middle Cay boasts two docks, one with an automatic boat lift, providing easy access to the water. Guests can enjoy various water activities like fishing, paddleboarding, kayaking, and canoeing. For a more tranquil experience, stroll along the scenic walkway, admire the lighthouse views, or relax by the fire pit. With the option to have your fridge fully stocked on request, this island offers the perfect blend of seclusion, luxury, and convenience.
Seamless Escape

Arrive at North Eleuthera Airport (ELH) and embark on a smooth transition to Middle Cay, Bahamas.

Efficient Transfer

Our dedicated boats or taxis will transport you to your tropical sanctuary in approximately 15 minutes.

Vessels to Choose

34 ft Intrepid or 22 ft Pursuit
Our seasoned captains pilot both vessels.

In just 5 minutes, our vessels will whisk you to vibrant Harbour Island for charming shops, exquisite dining, and lively nightlife, while Middle Cay offers a serene escape nestled between Harbour Island and North Eleuthera.

Imagine this

Your own private slice of paradise, surrounded by stunning turquoise waters. Middle Cay in Eleuthera is your personal tropical haven where you can lounge on your exclusive beach, dive into your heated pool, and enjoy sunset views from your private patio. Think of fishing off your own dock, or cozying up in a charming guest cottage with panoramic ocean views. And the best part? You’re just a quick boat ride from Harbour Island’s lively dining and shopping scene. It’s like living in a dream, but with all the perks of real life.
Surrounded by lush tropical greenery, the estate features swaying palm and coconut trees, a pool with panoramic ocean vistas, multiple lounging areas, an outdoor dining space, a beach volleyball court, and two private docks. After unwinding in paradise, guests can embark on adventures with our power boats and captain, exploring nearby islands, hidden swimming coves, and prime fishing spots. The warm, crystal-clear waters offer glimpses of colorful tropical fish and the occasional sea turtle. Indulge in the finest comfort with our premium European Giza cotton cooling linens and luxurious Hermès toiletries, ensuring your stay is nothing short of extraordinary.

LOCATE US

GET DIRECTIONS

Our Other Properties

Fantasea- Sint Maarten

Located right next to Oyster Pond in Sint Marten is Fantasea, a gorgeous beachfront home with a pool and hot tub looking over the ocean and docks in the pond. With five bedrooms and sleeping 20, and located on the border, its a fantastic house to stay in an see both the Dutch and French side of the island.

Featured on Season 5 Episode 10 of Carribean Life.

Inquire Now

Seaduction- Nassau

This house on the water houses up to 19 people with five bedrooms and four and half bathrooms. The swimming pool and hot tub look over the open ocean and the stairs lead directly into the calm and warm waters. The large windows around the house allow for ample light throughout the day. The house is in a great area being a short walk or bus ride anywhere.

Inquire Now

Frequently Asked Questions

What airport do we need to fly into?

The airport is North Eleuthra Airport and the code is ELH.

Our boat captain will be available 7 hours a day.

From Nassau, there are seven flights a day from Pineapple, Bahamas Air, and Southern Airways. If you are flying in to Nassau and catching a connecting flight, give at least 2 hours to catch the connecting flight. You have to clear immigration, go through baggage, and then customs. After which you will walk over to the domestic airport next door and check your bags in and then go through airport security. If you are flying in from Nassau please review weight restrictions on luggage for the airline of your choice. There are multiple daily direct flights from Miami, Fort Lauderdale, Atlanta, Charlotte, and New York to ELH.

The carriers that fly to ELH are: American Airlines, Delta, JetBlue, Silver Airlines and Aztec Airways.

From North Eleuthra Airport(ELH) take a taxi to Three island dock. The ride from ELH to Three island dock is one and a half miles. At Three island dock ask the water taxi to take you to Middle Cay. Middle Cay is located between Harbour Island and North Eleuthra. When you are a guest on our Cay, our boat will pick you up at the dock.